GA4 alternatives and comparisons
Peeko vs Microsoft Clarity for heatmaps, recordings and plain traffic counts
By Theo Marsh · Nov 14, 2026 · 9 min read
What each tool is for
These two tools answer different questions, so the comparison is less "which is better" than "which question do you have."
Clarity's overview lists session recordings, heatmaps, funnels and AI-powered insights. Its recordings page is specific about what a recording is: not a video of the screen, but a step-by-step reconstruction built from the captured HTML and the visitor's actions. A session ends after 30 minutes of inactivity. Its heatmaps page lists click, scroll, area, conversion and attention maps, says there is no minimum traffic needed to generate one, and splits click maps into all, dead, rage, error, first and last clicks.
Peeko does not work from a replay. It is one script tag with a site key, it sets no cookie, and it needs no configuration once it is on the page. What it keeps is page views, clicks, custom events and crawler hits. Five kinds of click are recorded with no code (outbound, phone, email, whatsapp and form). A goal is a definition rather than a counter, so a goal you write today counts over the months before you wrote it. A funnel holds two to five steps and follows a person rather than a visit.
If your question is "why do people leave this checkout page," a replay and a click map are the right tools, and Clarity has them. If your question is "where did last week's visitors come from and how many signed up," you want counts, goals and sources.
Price and limits, as of November 2026
Clarity's FAQ says it is "a free service forever" and that you "never encounter traffic limits or are compelled to upgrade to a paid version." It also states there is no limit on the number of sites per account and no sampling. We could not read Clarity's separate pricing page in a form we could quote, so the figures here come from the FAQ and the overview page.
Peeko is one plan on a slider from 100,000 to 10,000,000 events a month, 9 to 199 dollars monthly, with yearly billing at two months free. Every feature is on every size, with unlimited sites and unlimited team seats. The trial is fourteen days with no card and covers one site. An event is a page view, an outbound click or a custom event, counted over the UTC calendar month. AI crawler hits are never billed, and nothing stops recording when you pass your limit. Peeko's pricing page shows the 100,000 event size at 9 dollars.
So on price alone, Clarity wins at every traffic level, because zero is zero. The cost question is whether the counting side is worth 9 dollars or more to you.
Free does come with limits on getting your numbers out. Clarity's Data Export API allows 10 requests per project per day, covers only the previous 1 to 3 days, accepts at most three dimensions per request, and returns at most 1,000 rows with no pagination. A project admin has to generate the token. For a small site that is usually enough for a daily pull. It is not enough for a history or an hourly job.
Source: Microsoft Learn, Clarity Data Export API, Nov 2026. Retrieved Nov 11, 2026.
Cookies and consent
Clarity's cookie page says its typical usage sets non-essential cookies that store a unique pseudonymous ID. It lists two first-party cookies, _clck and _clsk, and five third-party ones: CLID, ANONCHK, MR, MUID and SM. Since Oct 31, 2025, Clarity enforces consent signals for visits from the EEA, the UK and Switzerland, and the FAQ says it uses IP address based geolocation to decide who needs to give consent.
The FAQ is also plain about what happens without consent: using Clarity does not violate its terms, but sessions become fragmented, so a visit to page A and then page B counts as two sessions, and features such as full session replay and journey continuity are unavailable. In other words, the feature you most likely installed Clarity for is the one that degrades first when a visitor declines.
Peeko sets no cookie. No IP address is ever stored. A visitor is the first part of a one way keyed hash of their address and browser string, and the address itself is never written to a database or a log. The hash behind the People number mixes in the date and is re-salted every day, so nobody can be followed from one day to the next. A second hash without the date tells a returning visitor from a new one and strings page views into a journey. It is the identity behind goals, funnels and revenue.
Two limits on that comparison. First, we are describing the documented design of each tool, not ruling on what any privacy law requires of your site; that is a question for your own counsel. Second, if you load Clarity, its cookies and consent rules apply to your site whatever Peeko does. Peeko does not remove them. Clarity also says it should not be used on sites or apps that target users under 18.
How long each tool keeps data
Clarity's retention page gives playback data 30 days, and click data, heatmap data and labeled or favorited sessions 9 months. The recordings page adds that after 30 days Clarity keeps 1% of recordings or 10 per day, whichever is higher, for up to 9 months. Deleted data cannot be recovered.
Peeko keeps page views, events and crawler hits for three years by default, and a site owner can set that window anywhere from 30 days to ten years. These are different kinds of data, so the numbers are not a like-for-like score. A replay is heavy and short-lived by design. A page view count is small and can be kept for years.
AI crawlers and AI visits
Clarity has moved into this area. Its Bot Activity dashboard is built from server-side logs collected through supported CDN and server integrations, and it shows bot operator, AI request share, activity by bot role and the paths bots request. Its docs say these are requests, and do not mean content was retrieved, grounded or cited. Clarity does not charge for it, but the cost page warns that Fastly, CloudFront, Cloudflare and Azure Front Door integrations might add charges from those providers. Separately, Clarity's bot detection is on by default and filters bot traffic out of the dashboard, heatmaps and recordings, and the FAQ admits some bot-like sessions can slip through.
Peeko does it with a separate server side path, because crawlers do not run JavaScript. The @usepeeko/bot-track middleware is ESM only, needs Node 20 or newer, has zero runtime dependencies and weighs under 3 KB gzipped. It matches a user agent against a curated list of 55 agents from 21 companies and files each hit under AI answers, Search indexing, AI training or Other AI bots. No address and no visitor hash exist on that path, and the raw user agent is kept up to 512 characters so old hits can be reclassified as the list grows. Visits that arrive from ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Copilot and Gemini are counted from ordinary page views by their referrer, with no middleware. We cover that method in how to count visits from ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Copilot and Gemini.
We have not run both tools on one site, so we make no claim about how their totals differ. Clarity's Citation dashboard also reports which pages are cited in AI answers and the queries behind them, after you verify the domain. A server can see that a page was fetched, but the question itself never reaches your server. The Clarity docs do not describe where citation data comes from, so read it with that in mind, as we explain in what an AI visibility score measures.
Where Clarity is the better choice
Choose Clarity, and do not feel you are settling, in these cases:
- You need to watch visitors. Recordings and the rage click, dead click and error click maps show friction that no count can. The product facts we can state for Peeko are counts, goals, funnels and revenue.
- You need heatmaps. Click, scroll, area, conversion and attention maps are all listed in Clarity's docs, and none needs a minimum amount of traffic.
- Your budget is zero at any volume. Free forever with no traffic limits, no sampling and no cap on sites.
- You build mobile apps. Clarity has a mobile SDK for Android, iOS, Flutter and React Native, according to its overview. Peeko's facts here cover a script tag and server middleware.
- You want AI summaries of sessions. Clarity's Copilot summarizes recordings and heatmaps.
Reading the numbers from an agent
Both tools reach an AI agent over MCP. Clarity's MCP server runs locally and needs Node.js 16 or later and a Data Export API token:
npx @microsoft/clarity-mcp-server --clarity_api_token=your-token-here
It inherits the export limits above: 10 requests a day, 3 days of data, 3 dimensions. Peeko hosts its MCP server at usepeeko.com/api/mcp. It is read only except for one tool that creates a site, it is reached with a bearer API key, and it is scoped by construction to the sites of the teams you belong to. npx @usepeeko/cli needs no install and speaks the same endpoint, so a command and a tool call return the same numbers. Setup is covered in giving Claude Code or Cursor read access to your traffic.
Which to pick
Use Clarity alone if your site is small, your questions are about page design and usability, and you are fine handling its consent requirements. Use Peeko alone if your questions are about visits, sources, goals, revenue and which AI crawlers fetch your pages, and you want no cookie. Use both if you have both kinds of question: they are separate scripts and neither needs the other.
If you are not sure what a page already loads, the free analytics checker at https://usepeeko.com/tools/analytics-checker takes any page and shows which of 18 analytics tools it loads, with no signup. If you are weighing a different incumbent, our Peeko vs Google Analytics 4 comparison uses the same method: each tool's own docs, dated, with the limits stated.