GA4 alternatives and comparisons

Peeko vs Umami, including when self hosting Umami is the better choice

By Theo Marsh · Nov 10, 2026 · 10 min read

You have a small site or a few of them, you want cookieless analytics, and two names keep coming up. This post compares them using only what each tool publishes. Umami's side comes from its docs and pricing page. Peeko's side comes from our own product facts and pricing page. We did not run both tools on one site, so there is no measurement here, only documented behavior.

What the two have in common

Both tools say they work without cookies. Umami's docs say "Umami's web tracker does not use cookies" and add that whether you need a cookie notice depends on the other services you use. Umami FAQ Peeko is one script tag with a site key, it sets no cookie, and it needs no configuration once it is on the page.

Both cover more than page views. Umami's docs list custom events, goals, funnels, user journeys, a revenue report, shareable statistics, an API and an official MCP server. Umami introduction Peeko covers goals, funnels, revenue and an MCP server too. The difference is less about the feature names and more about price, where the software runs, and what happens to bots.

What each costs at two volumes

Umami Cloud has four plans. As of November 2026, the pricing page lists Hobby at $0 for up to 100,000 events, Pro at $20 for 1 million events, Business at $200 for 10 million events, and a custom Enterprise plan. Umami pricing Peeko is one plan on a slider. The entry step is $9 a month for 100,000 events, and the 1 million step is $49 a month, as of November 2026. Peeko pricing

05101520100,000 events (Hobby)1 million events (Pro)

Source: Umami, Umami pricing, Nov 2026. Retrieved Nov 7, 2026.

Umami is cheaper at both points. The chart shows the gap: $0 against $9 at 100,000 events, and $20 against $49 at 1 million. At the top of the range the two converge. Umami Business is $200 for 10 million events, and Peeko's slider tops out at 10,000,000 events at $199 a month.

Price per plan is only part of it, so here is what sits under each number.

  • Umami Hobby is free, with 1 website, no team members and 6 months of data retention. It has no API, no integrations and no email reports. Umami pricing
  • Umami Pro allows up to 20 websites and up to 10 team members, with 2 years of retention. API access, MCP access, integrations and email reports start at this plan. Umami pricing
  • Umami Business has unlimited websites and team members, 5 years of retention, 5,000 included session replays, heatmaps and white labeling. Umami pricing
  • Overage on Umami is billed per event: $0.00003 on Pro and $0.00002 on Business, as of November 2026. Umami pricing
  • Peeko has every feature on every size, with unlimited sites and unlimited team seats. Page views, events and crawler hits are kept three years by default, and a site owner can set that anywhere from 30 days to ten years. Nothing stops recording when you pass your limit.

If you run one site under 100,000 events a month and can live with 6 months of history, Umami Hobby is free and Peeko is not. If you run several sites or want a teammate to see the numbers, Umami's cheapest plan with team members is Pro at $20, and Peeko's entry step already has unlimited seats. Compare the plan you would actually need, not the headline price.

What self hosting Umami asks of you

This is the part of the choice where Umami has an option Peeko's documented plan does not. Umami's license is MIT, and its comparison page says "self-hosting is completely free." Umami vs. Google Analytics The install docs list the requirements: "A server with Node.js version 20.19 or newer (22 LTS recommended)" and a PostgreSQL database, minimum version 12.14. Umami install

The Docker path is one command if you want the bundled database:

git clone https://github.com/umami-software/umami.git
cd umami
docker compose up -d

Docker Compose includes PostgreSQL. The default login is username admin and password umami, and the docs tell you to change it after your first login. Umami install

A single small server unit on a wooden shelf beside a window, with a hand reaching to check a cable, suggesting self hosted software that its owner maintains.

Free software is not free to operate. Umami's cloud docs say Umami manages hosting, updates, backups and scaling for Cloud users. Umami Cloud On a self hosted install, those four jobs are yours. A small virtual server and a database is a real monthly cost and a real hour now and then, and neither number appears on a pricing page, so we will not guess at one.

Self hosting also changes retention. Umami's FAQ says "For self-hosted installations, data is retained indefinitely unless you manually delete it." Umami FAQ That is longer than any Peeko default and longer than Umami Cloud's own plans, and it is bounded only by your disk.

One more detail for the self hosted route: the official MCP server is off by default there. The docs say to set MCP_ENABLED=1 and restart, and it needs Umami v3.4.0 or later. Umami MCP

How each one recognizes a visitor

Umami's session docs say it generates a session identifier from "the website ID, visitor IP address, browser User-Agent, and a rotating salt, without cookies." Umami sessions The salt rotation is configurable with SALT_ROTATION, and the default interval is monthly. Umami environment variables

Peeko's approach is similar in shape but differs in two places. No IP address is ever stored: a visitor is the first part of a one way keyed hash of their address and browser string, and the address itself is never written to a database or a log. The hash behind the People number mixes in the date and is re salted every day, so nobody can be followed from one day to the next. A second hash without the date tells a returning visitor from a new one and strings page views into a journey. That second hash is the identity behind goals, funnels and revenue.

Both are cookieless and both hash. The practical difference is the rotation window you are choosing between, and on a self hosted Umami you can change yours.

Bots and AI crawlers

Umami's environment variables page says "By default bots are excluded from statistics." A variable, DISABLE_BOT_CHECK, turns the check off. Umami environment variables So Umami's documented behavior is to keep bots out of your numbers. The pages we read do not describe a report of bot or AI crawler visits, and the FAQ does not mention crawlers at all.

Crawlers do not run JavaScript, so a script tag cannot see them in either tool. Peeko counts them through a separate server side path. The @usepeeko/bot-track middleware is ESM only, needs Node 20 or newer, has zero runtime dependencies and weighs under 3 KB gzipped. Peeko matches a crawler user agent against a curated list of 55 agents from 21 companies, and files every recognized hit under AI answers, Search indexing, AI training or Other AI bots. No address and no visitor hash exist on that path at all, and AI crawler hits are never billed.

Visits that come from ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Copilot and Gemini are a separate thing. Peeko counts those from ordinary page views by their referrer, with no middleware. If that split matters to you, how to count visits from ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Copilot and Gemini walks through it.

Working with an agent

Both tools have a read only MCP server. Umami's docs say it "lets MCP clients such as Claude, ChatGPT, and Cursor query your analytics" and that no tool can change settings, create websites or delete data. On Umami Cloud it requires Pro or above. Umami MCP

Peeko hosts its MCP server at usepeeko.com/api/mcp. It is read only except for one tool that creates a site, it uses a bearer API key, and it is scoped by construction to the sites of the teams you belong to. The command line needs no install: npx @usepeeko/cli speaks the same endpoint, so a command and a tool call return the same numbers. Setup is covered in giving Claude Code or Cursor read access to your site's traffic.

Where Umami is the better choice

Be plain about it. Umami is the better pick in these cases:

  • You want to own the server. Self hosting is documented, MIT licensed and free to download. If your data must stay on a machine you control, this decides it.
  • You want the lowest price. Hobby is $0 for one site up to 100,000 events, and Pro is $20 for 1 million events. Both are below Peeko's prices at those volumes, as of November 2026.
  • You want to keep data forever. A self hosted install retains data indefinitely unless you delete it.
  • You want session replays or heatmaps. Umami lists both on its Business plan. Peeko's product facts do not include either.
  • You want open source you can read and change. That is not something a hosted plan offers.

If one of those is your top priority, use Umami. You will not lose much by doing so, and it is a good tool.

Where Peeko fits

Peeko fits when you would rather not run a server and you want the crawler path. The reasons from the facts above: AI crawler hits counted under four labels and never billed, a goal that counts months before it was written because a goal is a definition rather than a counter, up to ten funnels and twenty goals per site, and every feature on every size with unlimited sites and seats. The trial is fourteen days with no card, it starts when you create your account, and it covers one site.

Peeko also does not hold a Stripe API key. The only credential it stores for revenue is the webhook signing secret, which proves an event came from your account and does nothing else. If revenue reporting is in your plan, how to report revenue from your site or let Stripe confirm it explains the two routes and why their totals are never added together.

How to decide in ten minutes

  1. Write down your monthly events. A page view, an outbound click or a custom event each count. If you are under 100,000, Umami Hobby costs $0 and Peeko costs $9.
  2. Decide whether you will run a server. If you will not patch Node and back up PostgreSQL, price Umami Cloud, not self hosting.
  3. Decide whether AI crawler hits matter to you. If they do, the crawler path is the reason to pick Peeko.
  4. Check what your site loads today. The free analytics checker shows which of 18 analytics tools a page loads, with no signup, which helps if an old script is still on the page.
  5. Run the one you choose for a week and read five numbers in the week after launch.

If you are also weighing a third tool, we wrote the Plausible comparison the same way, from each tool's own docs and pricing.

Limits of this comparison

Everything about Umami here is from its docs and pricing page as read in November 2026, and Umami can change either. The comparison page quoting a "$20" starting price is Umami's own marketing, and we used the pricing page for plan figures. We did not read Umami's source code, so the docs saying bots are excluded by default tells you what Umami states, not how its bot list compares with Peeko's list of 55 agents. We did not measure either tool's speed, accuracy or script weight. The chart plots list prices only, not what a given site would pay after overage.